Prince Street Pizza

Prince Street Pizza brings its famous New York-style slices and thick Sicilian squares to Toronto’s downtown core, offering a quick, high-quality meal for diners on the go. Located at The Well, this spot is ideal for pizza enthusiasts craving an authentic taste of NYC, whether for a fast lunch or a late-night bite. The menu features signature items like the Spicy Spring, known for its focaccia-like dough, fra diavolo sauce, and crispy cup-and-char pepperoni.

The shop’s takeout-heavy design mirrors the original New York location, complete with exposed red brick and celebrity photos, creating a nostalgic slice-shop ambiance. To ensure authenticity, they even use a custom water filter designed to mimic the mineral content of New York tap water. Customers appreciate the premium ingredients and the variety of options, including the Naughty Pie with vodka sauce and hot honey, as well as classic NY-style cheese slices.

While the pizza is widely praised for its quality and presentation, some diners note that it is best enjoyed fresh out of the oven, as the texture can change if eaten later. Additionally, the popularity of the brand can lead to long lines, and the prices are on the higher end for a slice shop. Despite these factors, Prince Street Pizza offers a satisfying and indulgent experience for those seeking a premium slice in Toronto.